Description
Help students explain similarities and differences with evidence.
- Grades: 7
- Format: Printable pages
Learning Objective
Students will compare and contrast information or story elements using text evidence.
What's Included
- Compare & Contrast Historical Fiction & Accounts Anchor Chart
- Compare & Contrast Historical Fiction & Accounts Practice Work
- Jack Thayer’s Own Story of the Wreck (Account)/An Unexpected Swim (970L)
- How New Orleans Drowned (Account)/This House Will Hold (980L)
- U.S. Woman First to Fly Across the Sea (Account)/Reach for the Skies (990L)
- Lieutenant Ruth Erickson Oral History of the Pearl Harbor Attack (Account)/Coffee at Albert’s (1020L)
- Deepwater Horizon Survivor Describes Horrors of the Blast and Escape from Rig (Account)/Escape From the Inferno (1010L)
- U.S. Shocks Soviets in Ice Hockey, 4-3 (Account)/Gold Medal Dreams (1160L)
- Test
- Nurse and Spy in the Union Army (Account)/Sisters in Battle (1040L)
Ways to Use
Whole-class instruction, small groups, independent practice, or enrichment.
Preparation
Preview the student pages, choose the activities, and print the pages you need.
Standards & Skills
Source-listed alignment: RL.7.9.





Jaycee Giles –
I used this resource for my evaluation and it went very well!
Ellen A. –
This was a great resource for targeting difficult skills my students were struggling to comprehend.
Betty R. –
The articles are engaging which helps my students to want to read them.
Mandi E. –
Used these articles as an extension to the historical novel I read with my summer school students. Students enjoyed the reading.
Maya D. –
This comparison pack was spot-on for helping my 7th graders analyze historical fiction vs. real accounts. The paired passages and guiding questions made discussion easy and meaningful.
Susan W. –
This is awesome! My students have loved this, and it is aligned perfectly! Thank you so much!
Alycia H. –
Perfect! I was looking for articles that would give my students good examples of what compare and contrast papers look like prior to having them write their own compare and contrasts. This worked perfectly. There were multiple structures shown and transition words were given as examples.
Thank you for the time saver.
Elizabeth A W. –
We used this resource for state assessment review. It was perfect for that!
Sharon V. –
This resource helped me to review for end-of-the-year testing by allowing us to compare and contrast two texts (historical fiction and historical accounts) as a class. It was nice having several passages so that students could practice on their own.
M M. –
This is exactly what I needed. Thank you for saving me a lot of work!
Elizabeth Perry –
These are always good article sets and I know that I can always trust that they are aligned with the standard.
Ella C. –
This resource was perfect for students to compare and contrast a fictional portrayal of a time, place, or character and a historical account of the same period as a means of understanding how authors of fiction use or alter history.
Britanie C. –
I use this as part of my bootcamp before standardized testing. It is great!