Compare & Contrast Events from Multiple Accounts RI.5.6 – Reading Passages RI5.6

$8.00

Students will compare and contrast multiple accounts of the same event or topic using text evidence.

Grades: 5 | Format: Printable pages + Google Slides

Description

Help students compare how different accounts present the same event or topic.

  • Grades: 5
  • Format: Printable pages + Google Slides

Learning Objective

Students will compare and contrast multiple accounts of the same event or topic using text evidence.

What's Included

  • 6 practice topic sets containing 18 accounts and short excerpts, plus 1 paired assessment containing 2 accounts.
  • 2 model texts, anchor charts, and teacher guidance for unpacking standards, prerequisite skills, and scaffolded instruction.
  • Scaffolded comprehension questions and answer keys.
  • Printable PDF and Google Slides copy link.
  • Classroom use
  • Use model texts for whole-class instruction, practice passages for small groups or independent work, and assessments to check understanding. Rainbow Reading encourages students to color-code evidence and build the habit of returning to the text to support answers.
  • Passage titles & Lexile levels
  • Coal Mining Children (3 accounts) — 790L
  • Ann Eggley’s Testimony About Coal Mining — 620L
  • Sojourner Truth on Women’s Rights — 790L
  • Freedom or Death — 970L
  • Women’s Rights Are Human Rights — 960L
  • It Is the 6th of September [1941] — 610L
  • Jacob Gens—Speech — 740L
  • Journey to America: Stories from Immigrants (4 accounts) — 970L
  • The Attack on Pearl Harbor Aboard the USS Arizona — 870L
  • Attack on Pearl Harbor from the Air — 970L
  • The Dire Calamity and the Greater San Francisco — 870L
  • Heroic San Francisco — 760L
  • Fair Oaks, California May 15, 1906 — 930L
  • Assessment: Excerpt from The Story of My Life — 970L
  • Assessment: Anne’s Letter to Sophia Hopkins — 820L
  • Model text: Rumbling Skies — Lexile level not provided
  • Model text: Helping Hand in Haiti — Lexile level not provided

Ways to Use

Whole-class instruction, small groups, independent practice, or enrichment.

Preparation

Preview the student pages, choose the activities, and print the pages you need. For digital use, check device and internet access and assign the version you will use.

Standards & Skills

Source-listed alignment: RI.5.6.

205 reviews for Compare & Contrast Events from Multiple Accounts RI.5.6 – Reading Passages RI5.6

  1. Teach Littles Love Others –

    This is a great resource to intentionally meet this standard.

  2. Rebecca L. –

    This resource was perfect to use with my differentiated small groups. The stories were engaging and the questions were great practice for this target.

  3. Laura M. –

    These passages were helpful for my fifth grade students!

  4. Kassie B. –

    This was a great resource to use in my classroom! My students loved it!

  5. wanderingfoxjourneys –

    This was a great and engaging resource to use in my special education classroom.

  6. Hailey C. –

    My students loved this resource! It was super easy to prep as well!

  7. Patricia G. –

    I needed an on the fly lesson/data collection/review sheet on a day I was unable to access my own assessments! This worked beautifully and has now been added to my repertoire.

  8. Amy H. –

    My students were excited about using this resources. It was an engaging learning experience for my students.

  9. Amorose Academics –

    This was and is a really good product to help your students gain a lot of information.

  10. Sarah W. –

    This is a very good and quality resource that was great to use in my classroom.

  11. Teaching Through the Pages –

    Love using ALL of the MagiCore standards based task cards in my stations. My students love using these everyday!

  12. Blair T. –

    I really loved this resource. I love the different topics that were included, they were very interesting to the students and provided background knowledge about events that they might have had little knowledge about. The questions were rigorous.

  13. Ciccarelli’s Children –

    I really love this resource, it is easy to use and student friendly.

  14. Katie Manna –

    This was a great no prep resource for extra practice!

  15. Susanna R. –

    This is a really fun resource, thank you so much.

  16. Claudia M. –

    These were great for my walk to read group!! We used these as a check in before report cards and it was so simple to print and use!!

  17. Aneceya K. –

    Absolutely fantastic resource! I was thrilled with the quality and creativity of this resource. My students were fully engaged and excited to participate, which made teaching a breeze. I highly recommend this resource.

  18. Just Peachy Learning –

    This resource was very helpful with my students and their learning.

  19. Camille Winicky –

    Excellent resource for teaching students to compare and contrast.

  20. Ashley Faison –

    I had a hard time finding resource to review this standard and this was great!

  21. Amy D. –

    My students loved using this producet in the classroom.

  22. Katharine Mankin –

    I love the challenge these products provide for students reviewing the skills!

  23. Kelly deBernard –

    Great Resource!! My students really enjoyed using this for review!

  24. Julie B. –

    This was a great practice and review for state assessments

  25. Sarah S. –

    Great assortment of topics to choose from, brought a lot of social studies knowledge into our ELA work and perfectly fit the standard.

  26. Rachel P. –

    Love these resources! They are always very engaging!

  27. Patricia M. –

    Thank you! I needed extra practice for my on-level kiddos.

  28. cynthia K. –

    Great resource! This aligns with the standards. Great purchase!

  29. GA Teacher on a Mission –

    I used with with my virtual students. They really enjoyed this activity and think it was the best lesson for the standard.

  30. MrsPugh –

    This is a great resource for the class. Very easy to implement!

  31. Angela T. –

    I love these resources! They are wonderful for differentiation and to scaffold learning.

  32. Alli N. –

    Students loved this resource. Students were engaged and it was easy to implement.

  33. Shannon H. –

    Love these for reinforcing and practicing our skills!

  34. amanda kowal –

    The readings were very engaging for my students! They connected well to the standard I was teaching!

  35. Samantha A. –

    These texts are engaging. I also like how the students need to refer to the text for evidence.

  36. Jessica L. –

    This was great for comparing and contrasting as well as teaching my students the RI.6 standard.

  37. Creatively Engaging Resources –

    This resource was easy to use and made planning easy. My students loved it!

  38. Brittany Reid –

    This was a very useful resource in my 5th grade classroom. Thank you!

  39. Christina H. –

    This was such a great resource. Very helpful for my students did so well with it. They were not afraid to participate.

  40. Cassandra S. –

    Love these resources. Bought as extra support for my students and it was perfect.

  41. Tracy K. –

    I love this resource for teaching ELA common core standards. Great to prepare students for items they may see on state tests!

  42. Laura A. –

    Enjoyed using this with 5th graders!!! Great resource!

  43. Shayla M. –

    Thank you!

  44. Kalyn T. –

    Great resource!

  45. Megan C. –

    Perfect to assign in Google Classroom. So many texts to compare and contrast events.

  46. Casey M. –

    I used this resource this year as a way to help my students prepare for the state test. Next year, I plan to use it during our regular curriculum as a supplemental resource.

  47. Jessica L. –

    Great activity to review what we have been learning in class!

  48. Nicole Y. –

    A perfect resource to use to review with before the assessment!
    Thank you!

  49. itssavhart – Savannah Harter –

    I was looking for more engaging text along with comprehension questions to help my students practice some of the standards they were struggling with. When I came across this resource, I immediately purchased it! My students were engaged with the multiple different texts, which helped them to be able to compare and contrast the different accounts in an easier way. I love this resource and plan to use it many more times in the future!

  50. Katherine K. –

    Great resource!

Only logged in customers who have purchased this product may leave a review.

Subscribe to get free content by email.

0